Quirks: the behaviour a faithful reimplementation must keep
Purpose
Section titled “Purpose”A careful reimplementer “fixes” some behaviour of the 1.14d Game.exe by accident: an unsigned divide made signed, a
draw skipped because its result is thrown away, a ≤ turned into <, a table edge read the “sensible” way. The reviewed
specs state these traps, scattered over their Reimplementation notes and step notes. This page lists them in one
place, by class, so that a reimplementation can be checked against the whole list.
This is an index, not a spec of its own (owner decision 1). Each entry restates one statement of a reviewed spec, with that statement’s tag and anchors, and links the section that holds it. It claims nothing new. The owning spec wins on any disagreement: read the linked section before you implement an entry, because the one-line restatement leaves out the conditions the spec gives in full.
How to read an entry
Section titled “How to read an entry”| Column | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Id | Q<n>, permanent from the Phase 1 review on: golden-trace cases cite it, so an id is never renumbered or reused; a new entry takes the next free id at the end of its class, and a removed entry’s id is retired. Q1–Q435 are in class order |
| Quirk | the behaviour to keep, restated in one or two sentences |
| Tag | the tag the source statement carries; a source note that holds two tags gives two entries |
| Anchors | anchors copied from the source statement (functions, addresses, runs, table columns) |
| Source | the owning spec’s section; nK is the K-th bullet of that spec’s Reimplementation notes, counted from 1 |
What counts as a quirk (owner decision 2): behaviour a reimplementer would plausibly “fix” or get wrong, in eight
classes, plus deliberate oddities that look like bugs and the community descriptions that 1.14d does not follow. Left
out: presentation (displayed names, strings, the quest log); a note whose whole content is a wall-clock rule (a
GetTickCount compare), while a branch that merely has a wall-clock threshold stays (Q387); and the table-loading
rules of data/excel and data/calc’s pools, with two row-index and code-resolution notes of hirelings and
items/properties, which a loader built to those specs implements as written (read
data/excel’s notes whole when writing the loader). Crash and hang paths are
listed as the specs state them: six from code readings (inferred) and three reached in kept runs
(confirmed): Q89, a fault logged on one crafted row, Q437, the fatal path reached on three paths under emulation, and Q448, the party’s ninth member under emulation; none was
provoked for this page (owner decision 5).
The check does not tell which clause of a note holding both tags an entry restates; those entries were read by hand at the Phase 1 review. The entry tables are the machine-readable form (five fixed cells per row, read, and list prints them as JSON Lines); there is no second file (review).
Entries
Section titled “Entries”| Class | Entries | C | I |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Arithmetic width and sign | 26 | 20 | 6 |
| 2. Rounding and float | 21 | 17 | 4 |
| 3. Wrap and overflow | 10 | 3 | 7 |
| 4. Bounds, comparisons and table edges | 79 | 62 | 17 |
| 5. Draw order and dead draws | 144 | 124 | 20 |
| 6. Data-dependent branches | 135 | 116 | 19 |
| 7. Timing and frame edges | 28 | 20 | 8 |
| 8. Multiplayer edges | 23 | 17 | 6 |
| 9. Deliberate oddities that look like bugs | 72 | 44 | 28 |
| Total | 538 | 423 | 115 |
1. Arithmetic width and sign
Section titled “1. Arithmetic width and sign”| Id | Quirk | Tag | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | The RNG’s low is u32 and the range reduction divides unsigned; a signed low is wrong for low ≥ 2^31. |
[C] | rng/README n4 |
| Q2 | The seed’s high word is not the constant 666 after Init: each step overwrites it with the carry word, so all 64 bits are state. |
[C] | rng/README n3 |
| Q3 | The animation rate divides (spd × X) mod 2³² by 100 unsigned for cast, get-hit, block, attack and default; only the moving branch divides signed, so a negative factor gives the fastest rate (unreachable on stock data). |
[I] | anim/timing n3 |
| Q4 | Calc opcode 04 reads its variable index unsigned (0–255): 04 80 is variable 128. |
[C] | data/calc § B; data/calc n7 |
| Q5 | manashift shifts by manashift & 31 (the processor’s masking of a byte that can reach 255); mask explicitly where shifts past 31 are undefined or saturate. |
[C] | data/calc n9 |
| Q6 | The string-table hash takes key bytes as signed chars: a byte ≥ 0x80 gives another home slot than the unsigned ELF hash (a miss walks max_probes nodes whatever the slot). |
[C] | data/strings n4 |
| Q7 | DR and MDR come before the resistance; a field they push negative skips the resistance and stays negative. | [C] | combat/reductions n1 |
| Q8 | Outdoor sizes, footprints and the mid cell divide signed; the preset rotation uses signed %. |
[C] | drlg/outdoor n12 |
| Q9 | Trade prices divide the stat and staff-mod sums by n unsigned and the affix accumulators signed: with n > 1 a negative stat sum divides as a large unsigned value. |
[C] | items/economy n4 |
| Q10 | Unique and set lvl comparisons are signed 16-bit (movsx), against an ilvl raised to at least 1. |
[I] | items/uniques-sets n9 |
| Q11 | A region’s raritySum is one byte. |
[C] | monsters/pool n7 |
| Q12 | The live special count nSpecial is an i32 compared through its low byte with MonUMin/MonUMax. |
[C] | monsters/spawn n11 |
| Q13 | Objects Xspace/Yspace are unsigned: a negative .txt value is a step of 249..255 subtiles. |
[C] | objects n7 |
| Q14 | Experience is unsigned: thresholds above 2³¹ and nextexp compare and store as u32. |
[C] | player/creation n4 |
| Q15 | With stock ExpRatio and shift 10, the kill-experience shift count (r >> s) + s is 10 or 11 (11 on the 70 rows at 1024, 10 elsewhere and above MaxLvl). |
[C] | player/creation n7 |
| Q16 | StatPerLevel is read as an i8. |
[I] | player/creation n9 |
| Q17 | The item bitstream’s width clamp is unsigned: a negative value written into an n-bit field becomes 2^n − 1, not 0. |
[C] | save/d2s n8 |
| Q18 | The gf stats writer clamps signed instead: a negative value of an unsigned stat becomes 0. |
[I] | save/d2s n8 |
| Q19 | An item property’s param is read unsigned (a 9-bit 270 stays 270). | [C] | save/d2s n13 |
| Q20 | CSvParam is read signed in the gf list; no stock row reads one. |
[I] | save/d2s n13 |
| Q21 | Missile function numbers are tested as s16, > 0 first, so row 568’s hit function does not run. |
[C] | skills/missiles n1 |
| Q22 | The regeneration tick adds stat 74 whatever its sign: positive heals up to the maximum, negative (poison) bleeds the player. | [C] | stats/states § E |
| Q436 | Signed and unsigned tests: a blank SubMissile1 (−1) passes the ≠ 0 test of mdo 21, 22, 23, 25 and 26; class 0 passes do 68’s test while do 73 and 80 refuse it; do 31 tests pettype signed, do 49 unsigned, and do 44 and 45 turn a bad one into 0. |
[C] | skills/catalogue n7 |
| Q475 | Store the Inventory gridX and gridY as bytes: the Hireling second-set rows hold 255 from blank cells. |
[C] | items/inventory n7 |
| Q476 | Row 13’s kind-9 bound compares an AI distance with a square, and row 22’s bounds are 32-bit signed imul squares of an i16. |
[I] | monsters/ai/machinery n3 |
| Q477 | PathDirCell’s & 1 is not a sign: it changes the cell only for an even non-zero minor term. |
[C] | path/search n4 |
2. Rounding and float
Section titled “2. Rounding and float”| Id | Quirk | Tag | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q23 | MulDiv is signed and truncates toward zero in every branch; the 32-bit branch is the one every stock MonLvlStats call at creation takes. |
[C] | monsters/stats § A |
| Q24 | Kill-experience level penalties are /256 factors (207/256, 13/256 …), not the community’s rounded percentages. | [C] | player/creation § G |
| Q25 | The party share’s quotient is stored as an f32, and each member’s input is trunc((f64) level × (f64) q_f32), the product never rounded to f32 (98 inputs of the run separate the two; two-member parties, the run’s case). |
[C] | player/creation § J |
| Q26 | The chance to hit truncates 100·AR/(AR+DEF) to an integer before the level factor; one combined expression gives other values. |
[C] | combat/to-hit n2 |
| Q27 | Calc ÷ is C division (toward zero), and a zero divisor gives 0 instead of a fault. |
[C] | data/calc n2 |
| Q28 | The hireling list entry floors (>> 3) where MERC_SetLevel truncates (÷ 8, ÷ 4); they differ for the negative products every stock row gives below its first band. The skill level floors (>> 5) in both. |
[C] | hirelings n4 |
| Q29 | A mercenary’s experience: another unit’s kill gives (gain × 86) ÷ 256 truncating, its own kill the full gain, then MERC_AddExp adds twice that; at or above its owner’s level it gains nothing. |
[C] | hirelings n13 |
| Q30 | Trade prices carry three running values P, S, R through every step, including those the mode discards; the order of terms matters through the later truncations. |
[C] | items/economy n1 |
| Q31 | The skill-based price terms divide S by 4096 and P, R by 1024; all other terms divide all three by 1024. The tables’ Divide columns are not read. |
[C] | items/economy n3 |
| Q32 | Quality-roll divisions truncate toward zero (−3 ÷ 2 = −1), not floor. |
[I] | items/quality n8 |
| Q33 | NoDrop is recomputed per pick in floating point; IEEE binary64 with round-to-nearest-even matches all 2 909 logged evaluations. |
[C] | items/tc n4 |
| Q34 | The game computes 1 − q, not the algebraically equal p·T/(1 − p); on stock data the two never differ. |
[I] | items/tc n4 |
| Q35 | Superior ethereal dur%: func 13 runs in the builder, then the ethereal roll halves the base stat 73 to ⌊max/2⌋ + 1 and stat 72 takes the re-evaluated 73. |
[C] | items/properties n13 |
| Q36 | So the +1 comes before the percentage: h + ⌊h · dur%/100⌋, which differs by one from the other order for some values. |
[I] | items/properties n14 |
| Q37 | MonHpAddPct truncates before it multiplies once max HP × 256 exceeds 0x100000 (HP > 4 096). |
[C] | monsters/stats n4 |
| Q38 | Two hpregen formulas: creation ((hp << 8)·r) >> 12, the stat callback ((new >> 8)·r) >> 4; they can differ by one, and a group member keeps the callback’s value. |
[C] | monsters/stats n5 |
| Q39 | The life rescale truncates a float32, and never takes current life below 1. | [C] | stats/aggregate n5 |
| Q40 | A path step that would pass its point lands on the subtile centre, so frames per point are a ceiling and the next step starts from the centre. | [C] | anim/movement n3 |
| Q41 | The missile step direction is a lookup in g_PathDirTable, not a trigonometric function. |
[C] | skills/missiles n10 |
| Q454 | A monster with few hit points has no regeneration: stat 74 is ((hp << 8) × r) >> 12, so 0 while hp × r < 16. |
[I] | monsters/stats § B |
| Q478 | calc1 of a healing or mana potion is a total, not a per-frame amount: it is scaled, maybe doubled and divided by len, and the division truncates, so a potion can deliver less than its total. |
[C] | items/use n1 |
3. Wrap and overflow
Section titled “3. Wrap and overflow”| Id | Quirk | Tag | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q42 | The level seed is a u32 sum that wraps, not a draw from the act seed. |
[C] | rng/seeds n3 |
| Q43 | MulDiv returns a 64-bit quotient outside the 32-bit range wrapped (its low 32 bits), not saturated. |
[C] | monsters/stats § A |
| Q44 | Crash path: MulDiv faults when a 32-bit product wraps to INT32_MIN with c = −1 (idiv overflow). |
[I] | monsters/stats § A |
| Q45 | Crash path: calc INT32_MIN ÷ −1 raises the processor’s divide error; only an edited formula with a variable divisor reaches it. |
[I] | data/calc § D |
| Q46 | raritySum wraps mod 256 with large Rarity values; stock data cannot reach it (13 × 2 at most), and no run exercised it. |
[I] | monsters/pool n7 |
| Q48 | XP_ApplyExpRatio switches to (exp >> s) × r when exp × r would overflow the shift; no kill reached it. |
[I] | player/creation § G |
| Q49 | A gold add over a cap writes 0, not the cap; callers clip first, so only paths that skip the clip (the PvP death write) differ. | [I] | items/economy n8 |
| Q50 | Hang and crash path: a progressive ring’s step count is used untested; 0 never ends, a negative count reads below the direction tables until the index wraps. | [I] | combat/delivery n11; skills/catalogue n8 |
| Q446 | The party share’s wraps: d² is 32-bit, compared unsigned, so a wrapped value inside the bound passes; the total’s product is i32, so past its wrap the total may go negative. |
[C] | player/party n6; player/creation § J |
4. Bounds, comparisons and table edges
Section titled “4. Bounds, comparisons and table edges”| Id | Quirk | Tag | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q51 | -seed 0 is impossible: the option applies only when non-zero, so 0 takes the clock path. |
[C] | rng/seeds n2 |
| Q52 | The to-hit clamp tests ≤ 5 and ≥ 95: a rolled attack is never certain and never impossible. |
[C] | combat/to-hit n3 |
| Q53 | The damage maximum is exclusive: lo + RangeB(hi − lo) never reaches hi. |
[C] | combat/damage n5 |
| Q54 | Life below 256 is 0: a hit that leaves less than one life point kills. | [C] | combat/delivery n6 |
| Q55 | Resistance: penalty before the cap (a player’s 115 % fire in Hell is 15 %, not −15 %). | [C] | combat/reductions n2 |
| Q56 | The floor comes between the penalty and the cap; it changed no logged value. | [C] | combat/reductions n2 |
| Q57 | Monster resistances are never capped: above 100 is immunity. | [C] | combat/reductions n4 |
| Q58 | Pierce does not lower a monster’s immunity. | [C] | combat/reductions n4 |
| Q59 | The player-row reduction loop stops at the first monster-only row, so for a player or hireling attacker the steal percents are not scaled by P. | [C] | combat/reductions n6 |
| Q60 | No minimum damage: nothing in the reduction path keeps a hit above 0. | [C] | combat/reductions n7 |
| Q61 | The life tick floors a player at 256 (one point), not 0; a monster’s tick can kill. | [I] | stats/states n6 |
| Q62 | The TCEx loader stops at the first empty name, and the item loop at the first empty ItemN (an Item5 after a blank Item4 is ignored); Picks 0 becomes 1. |
[I] | data/excel § G; data/excel n5 |
| Q63 | Monster references after the duplicate cr_lancer8 are off by one: a pool cell is a MonStats record position (723 is the second cr_lancer8), not a name to look up. |
[C] | monsters/pool n5; data/excel § H; data/excel n7 |
| Q64 | Language id 13 is not ENG: ids 0–12 give their entry, only ids ≥ 14 map to entry 0. |
[C] | data/strings n8; data/excel § I |
| Q65 | Crash path: a use byte of 13 reads the 0x18 bytes after the language table, and the string-table load would fault; only an edited use file holds 13. |
[I] | data/excel § I; data/excel n10 |
| Q66 | A string key lookup returns the lowest entry of a duplicated key and 0xFFFF for an absent key; an exact-match map can replace the probe walk only if it keeps both. |
[C] | data/strings n3 |
| Q67 | Entry 0 of string is indistinguishable from “not found” through GetByKey. |
[C] | data/strings n7 |
| Q68 | Collision: a footprint cell outside every reachable room returns 0x27 or more whatever the mask, so it always rejects (this keeps monsters off rows next to an inactive neighbour). |
[C] | drlg/collision n1 |
| Q69 | But a plus whose centre is in no room returns the mask itself; a mask of 0 then accepts. | [C] | drlg/collision n2 |
| Q70 | “Reachable” means the hint room or its near list: a cell of an active room outside the hint’s near list is “no room”. | [C] | drlg/collision n3 |
| Q71 | DT1 sub-tile rows are reversed: byte row 4 is the top row of the 5 × 5 block. | [C] | drlg/collision n5 |
| Q72 | SpawnPosOnTile never tests entry i − 1, turns i = 0 into 1, and returns the tile centre, not the offset cell it tested. |
[C] | drlg/collision n11 |
| Q73 | A tile pick sums at most 40 candidates, in DT1-list slot order (no stock key has more than 28). | [I] | drlg/room-tiles n2 |
| Q74 | Read past an end: Act1/Outdoors/Trees.ds1 is 12 bytes short, and DS1_Parse reads its last group’s y, w, h past the exact-size buffer (uninitialised heap). |
[I] | drlg/room-tiles n4 |
| Q75 | Read the missing Trees.ds1 bytes as zeros: 26 of 27 logged loads held zeros there, and that group’s draws (group, x, y) are reproduced with w = h = 0. |
[C] | drlg/room-tiles n4 |
| Q76 | Without KillEdge a room walks (w+1) × (h+1) cells, so its right and bottom edges are built by both rooms that share them (the bit-2 scan merges the second build). |
[C] | drlg/room-tiles n7 |
| Q77 | The filler test is exclusive (x < R.x + R.w), the neighbour test inclusive (x ≤ N.x + N.w). |
[C] | drlg/room-tiles n8 |
| Q78 | The bit-2 merge table has stride 7 but 8 columns: index row·7 + old orientation (column 7 is the next row’s column 0), and test Tr ≥ 0, E.o ≤ 7 signed. |
[I] | drlg/room-tiles n9 |
| Q79 | For the based maze types an exit mask of 0 gives base, not “no change”; only a zero table value leaves the Def as it was. |
[C] | drlg/maze n6 |
| Q81 | The hireling list level is playerLevel − 5 + (low mod 5), floor 2: 1 to 5 levels below the player, never above. |
[C] | hirelings n6 |
| Q82 | A hireling AR or defence clamped to 0 is not in the stat list at all. | [C] | hirelings n10 |
| Q83 | The affix pick draws Range(W + 1), so the last candidate in table order gets one extra unit of weight. |
[C] | items/affixes n2 |
| Q84 | Affix ids are merged indices + 1: subtract the block start and 1 for the magicprefix row. |
[C] | items/affixes n12 |
| Q86 | Cube forced affix ids are block rows + 1, taken with no weighted draw. | [C] | items/cube n9 |
| Q87 | A forced affix row skips the level window (row 17 took of Spikes, level 21, at alvl 19). | [C] | items/cube n10 |
| Q88 | That it skips only the level window has no separating stock case: the 8 stock forced ids pass every other test. | [I] | items/cube n11 |
| Q89 | Crash path: on crafted rows 72, 83, 84 and 90 at a low output ilvl, a side with too few groups picks 0 against a filled slot and the duplicate test reads a NULL record; the 1.14d outcome stops there, it does not draw again (the fault logged on row 83 only). | [C] | items/cube n12 |
| Q90 | Cube qty= and sock= share one byte; the sock flag tells which. |
[C] | items/cube n14 |
| Q91 | The socket count is start mod cap + 1, not a draw; keep ItemData+0x10, which a fallback rewrites. |
[C] | items/properties n4 |
| Q92 | Durability and quantity draws never reach the top: [⌊d/2⌋, 2⌊d/2⌋ − 1] and [lo, top − 1]. |
[C] | items/properties n8 |
| Q93 | Crash path: every quality *Divisor is a signed idiv with no zero test; reject a zero divisor at load or treat it as fatal, never substitute a value. |
[I] | items/quality n9 |
| Q94 | TCQuestId is the quest word itself, not word + 1 (Andariel is word 6); the Misc/Weapons quest column is quest object id + 1. |
[C] | items/quest-drops n3 |
| Q95 | A runeword row with one rune more than the sockets reads an unwritten kids[n] slot. |
[I] | items/sockets-runewords n5 |
| Q96 | The TC item count max is global to the call (6 for monster drops): the 6th item ends the whole recursion and skips gold find. |
[C] | items/tc n9 |
| Q97 | Unique durability is ×3 or ×2 of the current values, each capped at 255, only for a base with durability (GetUnitStat for 72, GetUnitBaseStat for 73). |
[C] | items/uniques-sets n10 |
| Q98 | Set weight 0 counts as 1 and a negative weight is kept; a zero total returns before any draw, a negative total reaches RangeB (no draw, 0) and the walk may run off the end. |
[C] | items/uniques-sets n11 |
| Q99 | Vendor stock level is not clamped to 99 in Nightmare and Hell (clvl 99 gives 104), while the gamble lvl is clamped to 5..99. |
[C] | items/vendors n7 |
| Q100 | A 33rd failure ends the whole vendor build, permanent items included, at the next limit test; no stock build reaches it. | [I] | items/vendors n8 |
| Q101 | A level’s monster candidate count is the number of leading non-negative slots (of 25), not the number of set slots. | [I] | monsters/pool n6 |
| Q102 | The variant duplicate check tests tries = 0, not ≤ 0: two equal existing sets make one try cost two, tries passes 0, and the loop runs on (a ≤ 0 control differs in exactly those 192 of 3 000 calls). |
[C] | monsters/pool n8 |
| Q103 | That loop ends with probability 1 but has no bound on its draws. | [I] | monsters/pool n8 |
| Q104 | The critter count excludes MaxGrp: RangeB(MaxGrp − MinGrp) + MinGrp. |
[C] | monsters/pool n9 |
| Q105 | The spawn density test is ≤: r = monDen passes. |
[C] | monsters/spawn n7 |
| Q106 | Object comparisons differ by one: slot test r ≤ ObjPrb, member walk r2 < sum, urn drop P100 < 21 (21 %), empty chest r ≤ 24 (25 %). |
[C] | objects n4 |
| Q107 | ShrinePick keeps its eighth code when no try passes LevelMin: no always-allowed fallback, no ninth draw. |
[C] | objects n11 |
| Q108 | XP_Compute returns 0 at the level cap. |
[C] | player/creation n6 |
| Q109 | For a non-positive input XP_Compute returns 1, not 0. |
[I] | player/creation n6 |
| Q110 | The eclipse period is 15 or 16, not up to 17: RandLoHi(15, 17) is one Step, period 15 + (low & 1) (run for level 44). |
[C] | quests/progression § G; quests/progression n6 |
| Q111 | Simple items have no n_filled: their bit 108 is the realm flag. |
[C] | save/d2s n10 |
| Q112 | Saved prefix ids are rebased, suffix ids are not. | [C] | save/d2s n11 |
| Q113 | Grouped properties (17, 48, 50, 52, 54, 57) carry one id, followed by the next ids’ values with no id and no param. | [C] | save/d2s n12 |
| Q114 | The save reader stops at 8 KiB (0x2000 bytes). |
[C] | save/d2s n14 |
| Q115 | The writer’s buffer is 8 KiB; no write passed it. | [I] | save/d2s n14 |
| Q116 | Missile LevRange counts every level: LevRange · lvl + Range, not from level 2. |
[C] | skills/missiles n8 |
| Q117 | The path’s tenth subtile crossing is unchecked: a very fast step can pass a blocked subtile after ten free crossings. | [C] | anim/movement n4 |
| Q437 | Crash path on reachable data: MissNovaCreate with n ≥ 41 (mhit 38, 45), do 123’s class at or past the Missiles count and st 20’s item class past the item count reach the fatal path. |
[C] | skills/catalogue n4 |
| Q447 | The party distance’s edge is inclusive and unsigned: d² = 6400 shares, 6401 does not. | [C] | player/party n6; player/creation § J |
| Q449 | Past Q448’s call is unread, and a party list holds at most 8 players, so no stock game reaches the call. | [I] | player/party n5; player/creation § J |
| Q455 | The crushing-blow cut is cb − MulDiv(cb, min(stat 36, 100), 100) for a positive stat 36, logged at 15 to 90 on a monster defender. |
[C] | combat/delivery § E |
| Q456 | At stat 36 of 100 or more the cap makes cb 0, no run met it, and the cut has no branch on the defender’s kind, so a player there takes no crushing blow: the same cut, after the player’s divisor 10. |
[I] | combat/delivery § E |
| Q457 | MAX_DROP stops a monster’s call at 6 items against Picks 7, the act bosses’ rows, logged on Duriel’s; do not raise it to the picks. |
[C] | items/tc |
| Q458 | The TC level walk reads TC[idx+1] with no bound check; stock data never reaches the table’s end, by a full-table check. |
[C] | items/tc § C |
| Q479 | MonAiEntryGet is not bounded on the state branch; the bound is MonAiInit’s, and it is signed. |
[I] | monsters/ai/README n3 |
| Q480 | AI row 125 uses the constant mode 5 and no sign test on Skill1. |
[C] | monsters/ai/machinery n4 |
| Q481 | Path type 15 reads the byte +0x91, not ctx.limit, and lim is 40 at least under a target unit. |
[C] | path/search n3 |
| Q482 | The search’s cell(n) takes g before the bound test, and the cells survive between passes, so a later pass can refuse a cell an earlier one wrote. |
[C] | path/search n6 |
5. Draw order and dead draws
Section titled “5. Draw order and dead draws”| Id | Quirk | Tag | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q118 | The n < 1 guard is not everywhere: Range/RangeB return 0 without drawing for n < 1, but RangePow2 and inlined constant-modulus draws (the % 7 of DRLG_ActCreate) have no guard and step anyway; each consuming spec states the form per site. |
[C] | rng/README n1 |
| Q119 | Reduce the new low: the step comes first and the result is taken from the updated state. |
[C] | rng/README n2 |
| Q120 | RangePow2Plus has no caller, and 14 inlined draw sites lie in 9 bodies with no static reference; a count of reachable draw sites leaves them out. |
[I] | rng/README § Algorithm |
| Q121 | Two roots: maps derive from the map seed game+0x7C; the game seed +0xD0 feeds every server unit, not the act → level chain. |
[C] | rng/seeds n1 |
| Q122 | The Act II tomb draws use an unguarded mod 7, not Range; every rejected pair costs two act draws and the loop is unbounded in principle. |
[C] | rng/seeds n4 |
| Q123 | Activation re-seeds the DRLG room from +0x04; carrying the generation seed over is wrong. |
[C] | rng/seeds n5 |
| Q124 | A DRLG room failing the RoomTile data test is not activated and makes no activation draw. |
[C] | rng/seeds n6 |
| Q125 | InitOne before Init is dead: it is overwritten at once and neither initialiser draws. |
[I] | rng/seeds n8 |
| Q126 | The missile pierce count seeds a local stack seed with Init(baseStat(owner, 328)) and steps it at most four times; it touches no game, unit or missile seed. |
[I] | rng/seeds n10 |
| Q127 | Skill and missile code re-seeds a missile’s seed (or a local one) from creator values, positions or stored words, and Armageddon’s period re-seeds the caster’s seed from a word kept per skill entry; the version-0 set builder re-seeds an item seed from its saved low word. | [I] | rng/seeds n11 |
| Q128 | The callback sets the new missile’s seed to Init(w + arg) and its PathPlan steps it before returning (20 steps for each of 442 Firestorm sub-missiles, 38 for each of 8 class-195 missiles). |
[C] | rng/seeds n11 |
| Q129 | Skill do 124 makes one RNG_Range(caster+0x20, 0x10000) on the caster’s seed after its record, aurastate and used-skill tests and bit 6, before STATLIST_Alloc or StatListSetEnd. |
[C] | rng/seeds n12 |
| Q130 | Do 124 stores that r on the used skill node, and Armageddon’s first period re-seeds the caster from it when no other writer of +0x18 runs between; Hurricane is stored the same r and does not re-seed. |
[I] | rng/seeds n12 |
| Q131 | Two seeds per combat event: the attacker’s draws to-hit, build, stat events, leech and stun; the defender’s draws the defence rolls (the block) and the cold, every time a chill is applied. One combat RNG desynchronises both units. | [C] | combat/README n1; combat/to-hit n4; combat/delivery n5 |
| Q132 | Draws whose results are discarded still happen: the player’s build on a miss, the builder’s RangeB(1) for players and monsters, the leech overlay Range(2) (only when both life and mana gains ran), the cold shatter roll on a monster that cannot shatter. |
[C] | combat/README n2; combat/damage n1 n2; combat/delivery n4 |
| Q133 | Draws that do not happen: a chance of 0 (block, dodge, deadly strike, crushing blow, open wounds) and a degenerate damage range hi ≤ lo draw nothing, on the paths the run checked; the monster HP roll differs (it draws RangeB(hi − lo + 1)). |
[C] | combat/README n3; combat/damage n4 |
| Q134 | Elements are built in the order fire, lightning, cold, magic. | [C] | combat/damage n3 |
| Q135 | COMBAT_PrgFinisher peeks: it saves the attacker’s seed words, steps the seed and writes the words back, so advancing the real seed there shifts every later attacker draw. |
[C] | combat/delivery n8; combat/README n4 |
| Q136 | The finisher’s entries 37, 39, 41 and 143 step the attacker’s seed once at entry, before their record test, even when they create nothing. | [C] | combat/delivery n9; skills/dispatch n4; combat/README n4; skills/catalogue n1 |
| Q137 | Entry 38 draws two or three times on the attacker’s seed after delivering the queued hit. | [I] | combat/delivery n9; combat/README n4 |
| Q138 | A weapon-share missile steps its owner’s seed at least once for stat 337, whatever its value. | [C] | skills/missiles n3; combat/README n5; skills/README n2 |
| Q139 | The missile’s deadly-strike step needs a non-zero stat 141, a negative one stepping the seed with no chance of success; its mastery step, with no used skill, needs a value above 0. | [C] | combat/README n5 |
| Q140 | Do not merge the two critical chains: the missile’s (stat 337 first, Q138) is not the melee build’s. | [C] | skills/README n2 |
| Q141 | A stat-event handler draws on its own unit’s seed: shiver armour (3) and skill on get-hit (21) on the defender’s, skill on death (30) on the dying unit’s, knockback, howl, stupidity, skill on attack or hit and reanimate on the attacker’s. | [I] | combat/delivery n12 |
| Q142 | Defence comes before the block: a miss draws no block; a running defender skips the to-hit draw but still draws the block. | [C] | combat/to-hit n6 |
| Q143 | Stat 328 (the request counter) rises on every skill request, before the checks, and seeds every pierce count: a refused request still changes later pierce counts. | [I] | skills/dispatch n1; skills/README n3 |
| Q144 | Both ternary branches of a calc formula run: every read, call and rand draw of the unused branch still happens. |
[C] | data/calc n1 |
| Q145 | Re-initialise the level seed in LevelInit; continuing from PresetLevelCreate’s draw is off by one draw per preset level. |
[C] | drlg/README n1 |
| Q146 | A preset with Files = 1 still consumes one level draw (Range(1)); Files ≤ 0 consumes none. |
[C] | drlg/README n2 |
| Q147 | Overwritten draws still count: an outdoor cell’s preset index and a maze rotation replace the instance draw, which was still made. | [C] | drlg/README n3 |
| Q148 | A rotating maze def’s first use yields (RangeB + 1) mod Files, not the drawn value; reset the counters at every LevelInit. |
[C] | drlg/README n4 |
| Q149 | LvlSubRoll draws on the room seed, at creation, before the activation re-seed; its draws never count in k. |
[C] | drlg/README n6 |
| Q150 | Lists are newest first: the maze growth pick indexes the list from the head, and the specials, merges, themes and the conversion walk it from the head; a maze level’s activated rooms are all preset (type 2) rooms. | [C] | drlg/maze n10; drlg/README n5 |
| Q151 | Maze growth takes its direction from the picked room’s own seed, not the level seed. | [C] | drlg/maze n1 |
| Q152 | A failed or locked growth step still spends the level-seed pick, the room-seed direction and, for an unlocked parent, the RoomCreate. |
[C] | drlg/maze n2 |
| Q153 | Maze probes create real rooms: each probe that passes the cheap tests spends a level draw, so the count depends on list order. | [C] | drlg/maze n3 |
| Q154 | Merge draws even at 0 (cannot link) and at 1000 (always links). |
[C] | drlg/maze n4 |
| Q155 | The hell start draws on R0’s seed, not the level seed. | [C] | drlg/maze n7 |
| Q156 | Unused draws: the Sewers A2 a on levels other than 47, and the 31 theme draws when nothing is themed. |
[C] | drlg/maze n8 |
| Q157 | Outdoor presets: every first use draws, Files 1 included, and the first index is (RangeB(Files) + 1) % Files; reset the counters at every build. |
[C] | drlg/outdoor n1 |
| Q158 | An overwritten border piece still drew: edge pieces placed where corners, seams, rivers and openings later go count their first uses. | [C] | drlg/outdoor n2 |
| Q159 | A failed placement still shuffles: PlaceRandom, PlaceNear, the waypoint and shrine passes make 2N draws whether or not a cell fits; PlaceNear makes 4N when it falls back. |
[C] | drlg/outdoor n3 |
| Q160 | Range(1) draws in PlaceList and in OutFillRandom (hi = lo). |
[C] | drlg/outdoor n4 |
| Q161 | The outdoor shrine draw comes first, before the shuffle, even with no interior. | [C] | drlg/outdoor n5 |
| Q162 | Act III’s jungle layout steps the act seed itself, not the link builder’s copy, at act creation. | [C] | drlg/outdoor n8 |
| Q163 | Jungle walk: Step(A) % 3 is drawn only when run ≠ 0 and the row is not the top one (C short-circuit); on the unpaired branch both further steps are drawn whatever the first gives. |
[C] | drlg/outdoor n9 |
| Q164 | Preset unit rolls draw in reverse file order: walk from the last file entry. | [C] | drlg/preset n1 |
| Q165 | A kept place_group unit places nothing in PresetMonSpawn, but its roll is still made and moves the seed. |
[I] | drlg/preset n2 |
| Q166 | Roll once per preset instance, on the first room that loads, and only when the map scan has not already rolled on the level seed. | [C] | drlg/preset n3 |
| Q167 | With Scan or Pops set, each drawing unit costs one level draw before the instance’s rooms are created, so later rooms’ +0x04 depend on the DS1’s content. |
[C] | drlg/preset n4 |
| Q168 | The room-seed roll uses the creation-time room seed, not the re-seeded one, and decides the units of every room of the instance. | [C] | drlg/preset n5 |
| Q169 | A tile pick with one candidate of positive rarity still draws; a key whose candidates all have rarity 0 does not. | [C] | drlg/room-tiles n1 |
| Q170 | Range(1) draws in the LvlSub group pick, Range(n ≤ 0) does not, and a group draw is made even when the group is then too big for the room. |
[C] | drlg/room-tiles n3 |
| Q171 | The neighbour re-pick steps another room’s seed: keep every built room’s seed and entries live after its activation. | [C] | drlg/room-tiles n5 |
| Q172 | Activation order is an input: server and client copies, or two players’ walks, give different k for the same room; gameplay uses the server copy. | [C] | drlg/room-tiles n6 |
| Q173 | Each LevelLinkBuild steps a fresh copy of the act seed; only level 27’s draw touches the act seed itself. |
[C] | drlg/warps n1 |
| Q174 | A link pick draws only on its first try; a backtrack resets the entry, which draws again. Three picks draw on every call. | [C] | drlg/warps n2 |
| Q175 | NearWarpTest can activate a room (its seed draws and grid) and step the level seed; call it exactly where the game does. |
[C] | drlg/collision n10 |
| Q176 | Release: one room-seed draw per mode-12 (dead) monster of a released room, taken before any other test; nothing else on the save path draws. | [C] | drlg/lifecycle § F; drlg/lifecycle § Draw order; drlg/lifecycle n3 |
| Q177 | A restored item record takes two game-seed draws even though its start seed is then overwritten. | [C] | drlg/lifecycle § Draw order; drlg/lifecycle n6 |
| Q178 | A re-created monster is a new unit for the seeds: a new game-seed step, a new unit seed and a new MonsterInit, with only its id, class, cell, stats 13, 7 and 6 and its mods from the record. |
[C] | chain n4; drlg/lifecycle n5 |
| Q179 | So a restored minion’s stat 12 is its level plus the handlers of mods 1–4 and its saved mods (a first instance at the pool level comes back 3 higher, later restores unchanged), and a restored champion’s is the flag-1 handlers’ result (+ 2). | [C] | drlg/lifecycle § H |
| Q180 | The player’s walk is an input: two games from one seed agree on level and room seeds, but their game seed and O diverge once rooms activate or populate in another order. |
[I] | chain n1 |
| Q181 | O, the object-region stream, is one seed for the whole game, starting at game-seed draw 2; every theme roll, handler, InitFn, PreOperate, operate and timer event advances it. |
[C] | chain n2; objects n1 |
| Q182 | A room’s seed outlives its pass: a later request on its tile, from another room’s pass, draws from where the earlier pass left it. | [C] | chain n3 |
| Q183 | The region append is chain state: a class appended outside the model rolls its sets then, and later creations of that class read them. | [C] | chain n6 |
| Q184 | Vendors and hirelings share the store seed: the hire build draws on it, and it must run at a seller’s first interaction start, before any menu action. | [C] | hirelings n1; items/vendors n5 |
| Q185 | A hire build draws a seed for every name before any pick: always n + 10 draws. |
[C] | hirelings n2 |
| Q186 | Draw 1 of every affix pick is spent, even when mustRoll makes its bit irrelevant and even when no candidate exists. |
[C] | items/affixes n1 |
| Q187 | A failed rare pick does not use up the slot: close that side and retry on the other, with no side step once a side is closed. | [C] | items/affixes n6 |
| Q188 | Magic properties are rolled inside each pick, rare properties after all picks. | [C] | items/affixes n7 |
| Q189 | The automagic pick runs after the ethereal and socket rolls, on the same item seed and alvl. | [C] | items/affixes n9 |
| Q190 | The low-quality durability draw is not on the item seed. | [C] | items/affixes n10 |
| Q191 | That draw is a RangeB on the unit seed. |
[I] | items/affixes n10 |
| Q192 | Superior draws are not a fixed count: redraw a tried row, stop when every row of the range is tried. | [C] | items/affixes n11 |
| Q193 | A quality-0 cube output still draws its quality roll, and its first fallback step draws it again from {S, 666}. |
[C] | items/cube n5 |
| Q194 | Cube copies (useitem, mod) take two game-seed steps and roll their mod lines on a new item seed; the unit seed comes back from the source’s Unit+0x28; a copied child adds two more steps. |
[C] | items/cube n6 |
| Q195 | Count two steps for each child of a copy with several (read from the child loop, not logged). | [I] | items/cube n6 |
| Q196 | A crafted item makes a side draw every slot, and its count is raised to the tier, never lowered. | [C] | items/cube n8 |
| Q197 | A sale’s copy is created (2 game-seed steps) before a store page is sought, so a copy no page takes still moves the seed; a refused copy moves nothing. | [C] | items/economy n7 |
| Q198 | The repair armour pick is cyclic from a random start (u the start slot, w the offset, empty slots skipped without weight); both draws happen whenever W > 0. |
[C] | items/economy n9 |
| Q199 | Base stats step the item unit’s seed (Unit+0x20); the property roll, ethereal and sockets step the item seed (ItemData+0x04). |
[C] | items/properties n1 |
| Q200 | A property block with min = max draws nothing. |
[C] | items/properties n2 |
| Q201 | Charges always draw, even when c ÷ 8 leaves a width of 1. |
[C] | items/properties n3 |
| Q202 | sock draws even when it then writes nothing (cap < 1), but not when the inventory size is 0. |
[I] | items/properties n5 |
| Q203 | The quality roll draws on the source unit’s seed, interleaved with the TC picks; a TC walk cannot be reproduced without the quality model. | [C] | items/quality n1; items/tc n3 |
| Q204 | A quality chance below 1 wins without a draw; a chance of 1 to 128 wins with one. | [C] | items/quality n2 |
| Q205 | Always-magic types still run the unique, set and rare tests, with their draws, before returning 4. | [C] | items/quality n7 |
| Q206 | TC picks and quality rolls step the source unit’s seed; created items get their seeds from the game seed. | [C] | items/tc n2 |
| Q207 | A sub-TC of total 1 with no NoDrop still steps the seed once per pick (Range(1)). |
[C] | items/tc n8 |
| Q208 | The unique pick is one draw on the item seed (created by a game-seed draw), not the source unit’s seed. | [C] | items/uniques-sets n1 |
| Q209 | A single unique candidate still draws (Range(1) returns 0 and steps), and the properties start from the stepped seed. |
[C] | items/uniques-sets n2 |
| Q210 | The “made” test comes after the pick: made rows stay in the candidate list, and the build fails when one comes up. | [C] | items/uniques-sets n3 |
| Q211 | Each fallback step reinitialises the item seed to {S, 666} and rewrites ItemData+0x10; a failed builder’s draws do not leak. |
[C] | items/uniques-sets n4 |
| Q212 | Scripted quest drops use a quest seed of their own, seeded from one game-seed step at game creation and kept across the game; the TC walk does not draw it. | [C] | items/quest-drops n4 |
| Q213 | Larzuk draws even when the bound is 1: a magic item with max 1 still costs one item-seed step. |
[C] | items/quest-drops n5 |
| Q214 | The Khalim chests give their gold piles first and their part after; the Act II chests give the item, then the chest drop, then the gold. | [C] | items/quest-drops n6 |
| Q215 | The imbue is a fresh creation on two game-seed steps; only the base, the ethereal state and a personal name carry over. | [C] | items/quest-drops n8 |
| Q216 | A runeword rolls on the seed of the child whose insert filled the last socket; a loaded rune’s seed is {startSeed, 666}. |
[C] | items/sockets-runewords n2 |
| Q217 | Runeword charges: the func 19 draw is consumed, then the charges are refilled. | [C] | items/sockets-runewords n3 |
| Q218 | A one-value vendor range still draws: RandLoHi(S, 1, 2) is 1 + R(S, 1); only hi ≤ lo skips the draw. |
[C] | items/vendors n1 |
| Q219 | An expansion stock entry in a classic game still makes its count draw before it is skipped. | [C] | items/vendors n2 |
| Q220 | Ring and amulet slots 0 and 1 draw lvl and a pick, then replace the pick; their lvl is kept. |
[C] | items/vendors n3 |
| Q221 | The upgrade draw comes before each stock item’s creation, after its quality draw (normal copies) or the magic count (magic copies); permanent items make it too in Nightmare and Hell. | [C] | items/vendors n6 |
| Q222 | One region draw R runs through all levels in id order, appearance sets included: leaving out any drawing level shifts every later pool. |
[C] | monsters/pool n1 |
| Q223 | The region init’s single draw is one step of the game seed, which the object regions, the store, quests and every later server unit step after it. | [C] | monsters/pool n3 |
| Q224 | A dropped class still costs a pick: isSpawn is tested after the pick and the slot removal. |
[C] | monsters/pool n4 |
| Q225 | The SpawnTypeRoll result 1 is folded into 2 before dispatch, but the roll’s last draw is kept. |
[C] | monsters/spawn n1 |
| Q226 | Champion or unique is a separate Range(boss.seed, 100) < 20 after the boss is placed, not part of the type roll. |
[C] | monsters/spawn n2 |
| Q227 | The leader’s seed serves its minions first: the MonStats minion count is drawn inside the leader’s creation, before SpawnGroup draws the group size. |
[C] | monsters/spawn n5 |
| Q228 | A one-monster group still draws its size (Range(x, 1)); Range(x, 0) does not, so an exact placement costs 3 draws, not 4. |
[C] | monsters/spawn n6 |
| Q229 | SpawnPosPick probes the point with a full radius −1 MonSpawnTry (3 room draws) and the caller creates there with a second one (3 more). |
[C] | monsters/spawn n8 |
| Q230 | A failed placement still consumes its ring draws and SpawnPosPick tries; failed members are simply missing. |
[C] | monsters/spawn n9 |
| Q231 | A unique’s mod count is Range(unit.seed, 1) + 1 + difficulty: the Range(1) is a real draw. A superunique’s extra picks have none. |
[C] | monsters/special n2 |
| Q232 | MonPlace 2 skips the champion roll: draw no Range(100) for it. |
[C] | monsters/special n3 |
| Q233 | The minion count comes before rndname: the unique minions are made before the handlers run, so their creations fall between the boss’s minion-count draw and its name-seed step. |
[C] | monsters/special n5 |
| Q234 | rndname runs for champions and pack members too (mods 1–4 always run): every special’s unit seed steps once in SpecialModsApply, twice for a superunique whose Mod1 is rndname. |
[C] | monsters/special n6 |
| Q235 | A superunique with MinGrp 0 still makes one RangeB(1) draw on its unit seed. |
[C] | monsters/special n9 |
| Q236 | The aura draw Range(Init(nameSeed), n) is local and touches no seed of the game. |
[C] | monsters/special n10 |
| Q237 | The monster HP range draws RangeB(hi − lo + 1), also when hi = lo (one step, result 0); only a reversed range makes no step. |
[C] | monsters/stats n1 |
| Q238 | Object population draws every slot: a group-0 or failing slot costs one room draw, a passing slot two even when the PROB sum leaves nothing. |
[C] | objects n2 |
| Q239 | Draws whose result is not used: each object handler’s P100 against 100, RandLoHi(S, 1, 2) in the shrine placer, and the discarded ShrinePick of a forced conversion. |
[C] | objects n5 |
| Q240 | R(O, 0) makes no draw: a cluster ring with step 0 (urns, classes 208/209) draws only the direction. |
[C] | objects n6 |
| Q241 | A chest drops from its re-seeded unit seed, not from O. |
[C] | objects n9 |
| Q242 | A revisited object makes all its creation draws again, then its saved interact, mode and sparkle win. |
[C] | objects n10 |
| Q243 | Of the trap effects, only types 8 and 9 draw the object-region seed, at the event (not reached). | [I] | objects n14 |
| Q244 | A starting weapon or shield still draws its socket roll Range(item.seed, 100) before flag 0x08 is tested. |
[C] | player/creation n1 |
| Q245 | NPC 266’s talk runs one e0 handler for two quest objects (25 and 30), so it draws twice. | [C] | quests/progression § G; quests/progression n3 |
| Q246 | Each arrival on a Position level by waypoint (type ≠ 13), NPC act change, resurrection or join steps that level’s seed once; a waypoint arrival into a town (type 13) does not. |
[C] | quests/travel § Draws; quests/travel n2 |
| Q247 | A town portal open draws three times: game seed, the town’s level seed (type 11), game seed. | [C] | quests/travel § Draws; quests/travel n3 |
| Q248 | The Harrogath portal’s type-5 lookup takes its one type-0 point with no draw. | [C] | quests/travel § Draws; quests/travel n6 |
| Q249 | An object’s opened mode is set without an animation start: no start draw at the operate end. | [C] | anim/timing n6 |
| Q250 | A damaging aura’s run consumes one draw on the caster’s seed in each run that draws, even when the state code itself draws nothing. | [C] | stats/states n7 |
| Q251 | Draw once per aura run, not once per unit hit: the one roll’s packet is copied to every unit the run hits. | [I] | stats/states n7 |
| Q438 | do 112 (MonCurseCast) steps the caster’s seed once before any test, so a refused cast still moves the seed by one (the finisher entries’ form is Q136). |
[C] | skills/catalogue n1 |
| Q439 | Not the caster’s seed: mdo 30 draws on the target unit’s seed, the shrine entries on the shrine object’s, st 55 on a local seed no unit keeps. | [C] | skills/catalogue n2 |
| Q440 | do 55 and do 58 (after their boundaries) draw on the target’s seed, and do 81’s per-unit roll on each unit’s. | [I] | skills/catalogue n2 |
| Q459 | A player’s Smite runs its hit test and its draws, then forces the hit bit (or ax, 1): the result is ignored, the draws are not, and the defence bits stay in the word. |
[I] | skills/catalogue § J |
| Q483 | A potion’s draws come before the amount test and run for a zero amount too; they depend on the user’s vitality or energy being above 0. | [C] | items/use n2 |
| Q484 | A refused AI move can queue nothing: a helper reaching MonAiMove with flag 2 clear returns 0 on refusal with no idle and no draw; only flag 2 adds the draw and the ring or the idle. |
[I] | monsters/ai/catalogue n1 |
| Q485 | An AI slot may be read twice: row 7’s second aip(3) draw is a new draw on the same slot, and each chance is one step. |
[I] | monsters/ai/catalogue n2 |
| Q486 | chance(K) short-circuits as written: row 13’s second chance(1) is drawn only with a corpse, row 22’s aip3 only with Skill2 ≥ 0 and a wounded unit. Keep the order of the tests. |
[I] | monsters/ai/machinery n1 |
| Q487 | The wanderer tick runs on every room of a walked act, not only on new ones: a frame that creates one room steps every room seed of its act once. | [C] | sim/frame n7 |
| Q529 | Act I’s OneOrTwo makes its second draw on the else branch only: the (r & 3) = 0 branch places twice and returns, so a call with s = 1 makes one Step there and two on the other branch. |
[C] | drlg/outdoor n14 |
6. Data-dependent branches
Section titled “6. Data-dependent branches”| Id | Quirk | Tag | Anchors | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q252 | Calc 02 (Fire Wall’s unclosed () ends the evaluation with the top of the stack, like 00. |
[C] | — | data/calc § B; data/calc n3 |
| Q253 | A calc compile can fail where a permissive parser succeeds (min(-1,lvl), - -5, a lone space …): the game stores −1 and the formula evaluates to 0. |
[C] | CALC_PushOperator |
data/calc n6 |
| Q254 | The monster Crit doubles every damage field, physical and elemental. |
[C] | MonCritDouble |
combat/damage n6 |
| Q255 | A player’s critical or deadly strike doubles only physical damage. | [C] | — | combat/damage n6 |
| Q256 | Leech uses the reduced, life-capped physical damage; elemental damage never leeches. | [C] | COMBAT_Leech |
combat/delivery n3 |
| Q257 | Absorb heals from percent absorb, and only a positive amount. | [C] | COMBAT_Absorb |
combat/delivery n7 |
| Q258 | Flat absorb heals too. | [C] | COMBAT_Absorb |
combat/delivery n7 |
| Q259 | The assassin finishing moves (do 42, 46, 50, 52) call the finisher with their own queued hit and then deliver; the call sites and the calls of do 42, 46 (bad-id path) and 50 are confirmed. | [C] | — | combat/delivery n10 |
| Q260 | Do 46 runs the finisher only on a hit but delivers on both paths (its valid-id calls and the deliveries after them). | [I] | — | combat/delivery n10 |
| Q261 | SKILLS_PayCost returns 0 for a row with mana and lvlmana both 0 (scrolls, books, Unsummon). |
[C] | SKILLS_PayCost |
combat/delivery n13 |
| Q262 | None of its three callers tests that return: a failed or zero payment still casts, so a reimplementation that refuses on 0 refuses those skills. | [C] | — | combat/delivery n13 ; skills/dispatch n2 |
| Q263 | An item Nova, Frost Nova or Chain Lightning runs its ItemEffect only from a skill-on-attack, -kill or -hit stat without ItemTgtDo (the effect flag only handler 20 sets); from other entries it runs the row’s srvdofunc. |
[C] | — | combat/delivery n14 ; skills/dispatch n7 |
| Q264 | Classic resistance penalties are the constants −20 (Nightmare) and −50 (Hell), not DifficultyLevels’ ResistPenalty. |
[C] | COMBAT_ResistFor |
combat/reductions n3 |
| Q265 | Cold and freeze lengths use cold resistance; the poison length uses stat 110. | [C] | g_DamageResistTable |
combat/reductions n5 |
| Q266 | Neither the chance to hit nor the block chance has a difficulty branch; only the block form differs between classic and expansion. | [C] | COMBAT_ToHitRoll, COMBAT_DefenceRoll |
combat/to-hit n5 |
| Q267 | The collision grid depends on activation order: keep, per room, which near rooms were active at its activation, and never re-stamp a grid when a neighbour activates. | [C] | COLL_MapBuild |
drlg/collision n4 |
| Q268 | The monster bit does not block a default spawn; only the 0x1000 centre bits do. |
[C] | COLL_PatternMark |
drlg/collision n6 |
| Q269 | A wraith’s creation pattern 5 lasts only until the refresh: mark it, then run the refresh before the next test. | [C] | PathPatternRefresh |
drlg/collision n7 |
| Q270 | Unmarks are not reference-counted: clearing one footprint clears the shared bits of an overlapping unit. | [C] | COLL_PatternUnmark |
drlg/collision n8 |
| Q271 | LogicBoxSingle resets the level’s region counter: flood ids after a single-box room restart from 1. |
[C] | LogicBoxSingle |
drlg/collision n12 |
| Q272 | The collision grid changes as a spawn pass runs: each placed monster marks cells later members test. | [C] | CollisionTest |
monsters/spawn n10 |
| Q273 | A re-created monster marks the grid like a pass creation, outside any window; leaving its marks out fails later position tests. | [C] | COLL_WHTest |
chain n5 |
| Q274 | A restored room is not populated again: the new-rooms walk populates once and restores once per activation. | [C] | NewRoomsUpdate |
drlg/lifecycle § D; drlg/lifecycle n4 |
| Q275 | A room reference counts paths, not rooms: a room reached through several near lists at one distance holds one reference per path. | [C] | DrlgRefAddNear |
drlg/lifecycle § B; drlg/lifecycle n7 |
| Q276 | DefFromExits unlocks: a locked parent that a later fixed room recomputes becomes unlocked again. |
[C] | MazeRoomDefFromExits |
drlg/maze n5 |
| Q277 | The Temple rotation is mod 3, and the Tomb rotation comes from the Prev record, not a draw. |
[C] | MazeSpecialsTemple, MazeSpecialsTomb |
drlg/maze n9 |
| Q278 | The seam opening is a cell write (index 3, 4 on level 17, into bits 16–19 after placement), not a rotation index. | [C] | OutBorderBuild |
drlg/outdoor n6 |
| Q279 | Use the link builder’s size: Blood Moor and the Barricade levels are not their Levels size. |
[C] | LinkPick, LinkPick |
drlg/outdoor n7 |
| Q280 | Preset path points stay absolute; only the unit’s own position becomes room-relative. | [C] | DRLG_PresetUnitsToRoom |
drlg/preset n6 |
| Q281 | Populate 0 does not suppress preset units. |
[C] | — | drlg/preset n7 |
| Q282 | A re-prepared room is not emptied: the second pass adds nothing and the previous unit list stays. | [C] | DRLG_PresetUnitsToRoom |
drlg/preset n9 |
| Q283 | A released room keeps its DT1 list, neighbour list and +0x04, not its entries; neighbours keep what its first build merged into them. |
[C] | RoomTilesRelease |
drlg/room-tiles n10 |
| Q284 | Hidden-warp picks are floor picks (orientation 0, key (0, s & 0x3F, 4 + i)) whatever the warp cell’s orientation. |
[C] | HiddenWarpTilesAdd |
drlg/room-tiles n11 |
| Q285 | Keep real tile chains (+0x20 links that the warp steps re-set), not arrays of entries. |
[C] | WarpTileAdd, NeighbourTileFind |
drlg/room-tiles n12 |
| Q286 | Cell bit 0x8 follows the merging cell’s bit 31: CellBits clears it as well as sets it, and a merge runs CellBits again on the old word. |
[C] | RoomTileSetFlags |
drlg/room-tiles n13 |
| Q287 | Pre-fill the room flags with the seam bits (Warp −1 slots), even for instances with Scan and Pops 0, and do not make points of them. |
[C] | DRLG_PresetMapScan, LevelWarpPointsBuild |
drlg/warps n3 |
| Q288 | The waypoint flag does not carry to the next room in the warp point build. | [C] | LevelWarpPointsBuild |
drlg/warps n4 |
| Q289 | Warp pairing needs the fallback; rank alone mispairs the Durance and some caves. | [C] | WarpPairLink |
drlg/warps n5 |
| Q290 | Reset the warp points at every build: LevelUnload clears them and each LevelInit rebuilds them. |
[C] | LevelUnload, LevelWarpPointsBuild |
drlg/warps n6 |
| Q291 | Two hireling rows: RollEntry always uses the type’s first band (list price and stats), MERC_SetLevel the band holding the mercenary’s level. |
[C] | HIRELING_RollEntry, MERC_SetLevel |
hirelings n3 |
| Q292 | A Nightmare or Hell hire list uses the Normal row’s name range; only the type draw uses the game’s difficulty. | [C] | HIRE_GetNameRange |
hirelings n5 |
| Q293 | 1.14d has one Resist, Resist/Lvl pair, applied to the four resistances and divided by 4. |
[C] | — | hirelings n8 |
| Q294 | A loaded mercenary’s Id is the saved one: PETS_SetInfo overwrites the Id MERC_Init derived from the seed and difficulty. |
[C] | PETS_SetInfo |
hirelings n11 |
| Q295 | A classic save’s mercenary is not created outside its act; the header is kept in the save. | [C] | MERC_Create |
hirelings n12 |
| Q296 | magic lvl bases weight affixes by frequency × level, not frequency. |
[C] | — | items/affixes n4 |
| Q297 | classspecific does not keep a row off classless items; only the row’s itype list does. |
[C] | — | items/affixes n8 |
| Q298 | The cube takes the first fitting row in table order, and the item count is exact: an extra item refuses every stock row, a stack counts as one. | [C] | CUBE_Transmute |
items/cube n1 |
| Q299 | A cube input claims every matching item, not qty of them, before the comparison. |
[C] | CUBE_MatchInput |
items/cube n2 |
| Q300 | Input 1 drives all three cube outputs, with output A’s flags (its ilvl for b ilvl, c ilvl). |
[I] | — | items/cube n3 |
| Q301 | An ethereal cube upgrade writes the plain values on the re-based copy; the mod line’s ITEMS_MakeEthereal applies ×3/2 afterwards. |
[C] | ITEMS_MakeEthereal |
items/cube n7 |
| Q302 | A matching row that produces nothing (the Pandemonium rows, a refused cow portal) consumes nothing. | [C] | — | items/cube n13 |
| Q303 | The low quality replaces the automagic accumulators with the halves; it does not add. | [C] | — | items/economy n5 |
| Q304 | A sale takes the lower of two prices when the item enters the store, so a damaged item does not sell above its repaired copy. | [C] | NPC_SellItem |
items/economy n6 |
| Q305 | ac% raises the base defense to maxac + 1 per block, before ethereal ×3/2. |
[C] | — | items/properties n7 |
| Q306 | Quivers ignore spawnstack; misc items honour it. |
[C] | ItemTypeQuiver |
items/properties n9 |
| Q307 | A property value of 0 writes nothing, and slot 1 then hands prev 0 on, so a later reuse slot draws its own value. | [C] | PROP_WriteStat |
items/properties n10 |
| Q308 | op is not applied at creation: the lists hold raw values (<< ValShift), and …/lvl stats hold par. |
[C] | PROP_WriteStat |
items/properties n11 |
| Q309 | The uber key matters for drops through Normal/NormalDivisor only. |
[C] | ItemRatio.txt:Normal |
items/quality n5 |
| Q310 | Superior and normal/low ignore magic find and the TC ratio words. | [C] | — | items/quality n6 |
| Q311 | The difficulty passed to ITEMRATIO_Select is unused: do not key rows by difficulty. |
[I] | ITEMRATIO_Select |
items/quality n10 |
| Q312 | Bit 0 is not one of Duriel’s tested quest bits: a character with bit 0 but no bit 5 still gets Durielq; only bit 5 (set at the kill) ends it. |
[C] | MonStats.txt:TCQuestCP |
items/quest-drops n2 |
| Q313 | A scripted quality is not always the item’s: a base with Misc unique 1 comes back at 7. |
[C] | — | items/quest-drops n7 |
| Q314 | The forge’s rune is one per game, and the hammer is found only with stat 356 ≥ the difficulty and must be equipped. | [C] | — | items/quest-drops n9 |
| Q315 | Runeword properties are applied with the rune as “the item”: the seed, the weapon and armour tests and func 23 look at the child; the parent is only the target list. | [C] | RUNEWORD_Apply |
items/sockets-runewords n1 |
| Q316 | Low quality qualifies for a runeword and ethereal is not tested; quality 9 is excluded with crafted. | [C] | — | items/sockets-runewords n4 |
| Q317 | Classic games accept runes in sockets and apply their group like any rune. | [C] | ITEMS_InsertSocket |
items/sockets-runewords n7 |
| Q318 | No runeword can form in a classic game: no stock row is classic-legal. | [I] | Runes.txt:Rune1, Runes § Survey |
items/sockets-runewords § D; items/sockets-runewords n7 |
| Q319 | A loaded socket count is kept above the creation clamps (SetSocketsOnLoad). |
[C] | ITEMS_SetSocketsOnLoad |
items/sockets-runewords n8 |
| Q320 | The quality socket clamps belong to creation only (SetSockets); no run executed them. |
[I] | ITEMS_SetSockets |
items/sockets-runewords n8 |
| Q321 | The TC level walk is forward-only from the base TC, which is kept even when its level is above mlvl. | [C] | TC_GetByIndex |
items/tc n7 |
| Q322 | Classic games differ in the draw total, the entry selection, the throwable re-pick and the Long Sword; the classic sessions reproduce the total, its two clauses, the scan, the refund, and (forced) the bound of 10 and lsd. |
[C] | TC_ResolveDrops |
items/tc n11 |
| Q323 | Classic item rejection and the ratio raises differ too; the expansion-only skip, the scan off the end and the version reject have no stock case. |
[I] | — | items/tc n11 |
| Q324 | Set items take their version from their set and have no enabled, ladder or once-per-game test. |
[C] | Sets.txt:version |
items/uniques-sets n8 |
| Q325 | Item version 0 builds by other rules (first match, no draw, ×5 durability for uniques; a set membership walk for sets); drops never reach them. | [I] | ItemBuildSetV0 |
items/uniques-sets n12 |
| Q326 | Equal-level gamble order is data: use the game’s table, not a stable sort of Gamble.txt. | [C] | g_GambleList |
items/vendors n4 |
| Q327 | MagicLvl is a gate, not a cap: the affix level is not clamped to it. |
[C] | — | items/vendors n9 |
| Q328 | The monster pool is fixed per game at creation, from the game seed and the difficulty only; map seed and level entry order do not affect it. | [C] | MonRegionsInit |
monsters/pool n2 |
| Q329 | The no-record fallback of the monster level (1) has no stock case. | [I] | LevelMonLvl |
monsters/pool n10 |
| Q330 | Hirelings are created at normal’s MonStats Level (d forced to 0), then levelled by MERC_SetLevel; class 560 has no Hireling row. |
[C] | HirelingType, Hireling.txt:Class |
monsters/pool n11 |
| Q331 | When the first pick of a spawn attempt returns no class record, the pass returns at once and does not count the room as populated. | [I] | — | monsters/spawn n12 |
| Q332 | The spawn pass has no expansion branch; the flag enters only through the region and the champion mod pick (399 classic passes reproduced by the same model). | [C] | RoomPopulate, ChampionModPick |
monsters/spawn n13 |
| Q333 | A pack member is not rolled: every member and every MonPlace 3 champion gets mod 16, not the boss’s champion mod. | [C] | ChampionMemberMark |
monsters/special n4 |
| Q334 | Copy the boss’s xfer mods when each minion is created, from the minion’s own first free slot, not after the handlers. |
[C] | ModsXferCopy |
monsters/special n7 |
| Q335 | A superunique’s extra mod picks ignore its post-create mods: have holds only the fixed mods. |
[C] | — | monsters/special n8 |
| Q336 | The expansion flag enters the special path only through ModEligible’s version test, leaving classic champions champion (16) as their only candidate. |
[C] | Game+0x070 |
monsters/special n11 |
| Q337 | Stat 6 follows stat 7 through the callback, also in the classic halving. | [C] | MonStatCallback |
monsters/stats n6 |
| Q338 | Classic Nightmare and Hell use two levels: the base-stat MonLvl row from Level(N)/Level(H), the level stat (enchant DM row, leveladd, aura level) from Level + 25·d. |
[C] | MonClassicDiffAdjust |
monsters/stats n7 |
| Q339 | Mod order matters: the resist count k is taken when each handler runs, and stoneskin doubles defence before it tests k. |
[C] | UModResist |
monsters/stats n8 |
| Q340 | A champion-pack member is not a group member of its leader: its own flag-1 pass, the champion HP %. | [C] | SpecialModsApply |
monsters/stats n11 |
| Q341 | Object handler 1 tests with the member’s size, whatever class the list draw gave. | [C] | OBJPOP_Clusters |
objects n12 |
| Q342 | A revisit restores objects oldest first, as the plain class: a DS1 580/581 chest comes back without its pseudo-object draws. | [C] | RoomInactiveUnitsRestore |
objects n13 |
| Q343 | Trap level remap: a type-4 trap in level 35 fires firebolts. | [C] | OBJ_TrapEvent |
objects n15 |
| Q344 | The other remaps: below level 40 types 1 and 4, and type 3 outside level 25, fire firebolts; from level 75 a type-8 trap does too. Take the function from the event’s level. | [I] | OBJ_TrapEvent |
objects n15 |
| Q345 | The player unit seed is not in the save (its only seed is map_seed); items keep their Unit+0x28 as the saved seed. |
[C] | D2S_ReadHeader |
player/creation n2 |
| Q346 | StartSkill is a skill granted by item1’s item_singleskill at base level 0, not a skill point. |
[C] | StartItemCreate |
player/creation n3 |
| Q347 | The level is recomputed from the total experience stat, and level/nextexp are written even when d ≤ 0. |
[C] | PLAYER_LevelUp |
player/creation n5 |
| Q348 | Within one event the quests run from object 40 down to row 0’s object (later acts first). | [I] | QUESTS_InitGame |
quests/progression § B; quests/progression n1 |
| Q349 | “Switched off” is not inert: the forced events still reach a switched-off quest, and handlers that test only the NPC, the message or the word’s own bits still write (for the handlers and branches the runs reached). | [C] | — | quests/progression § C; quests/progression n2 |
| Q350 | The loader sets quest bit 15 from a saved bit 1 (and clears 13 and 14). | [C] | QUESTRECORD_LoadBytes |
quests/progression § A; quests/progression n4 |
| Q351 | Checksum before size: a save with both wrong fails with 6, not 5. | [C] | D2S_ReadHeader |
save/d2s n2 |
| Q352 | The save checksum sums the whole file with 0x00C–0x00F as 0, after file_size is filled; the reader zeroes the stored copy before summing. |
[C] | D2S_Checksum |
save/d2s n1 |
| Q353 | The header level is output only: write it from stat 12, ignore it on load. |
[C] | — | save/d2s n3 |
| Q354 | Max life and mana come from the file (stats 7 and 9 are not recomputed at load); current life and mana are restored as read. | [C] | D2S_LoadFinish |
save/d2s n5 |
| Q355 | Item flags change on the way: the writer clears bit 19 and sets 23; the reader strips 25, sets 19 and clears 13. | [C] | ItemCreateFromSave, ITEMS_SerializeBits |
save/d2s n6 |
| Q356 | The saved item seed is the unit seed’s initial value: the loaded unit seed is RNG_SeedInit’s {seed, 666}, whatever state it had reached. |
[C] | RNG_SeedInit |
save/d2s n7 |
| Q357 | Fixed item fields apply Save Add. |
[C] | — | save/d2s § I; save/d2s n9 |
| Q358 | Neither fixed fields nor followers apply ValShift. |
[I] | — | save/d2s n9 |
| Q359 | One delay state blocks all delayed skills, not only the one cast. | [I] | SKILLS_DelayOk |
skills/dispatch n5 |
| Q360 | A monster’s bit 6 is set by its AI; in modes 4, 5, 7, 8, 9 and 16–20 its start leaves it set, so its do runs only through the attack-frame handler, while mode 14’s start clears it, so its do runs on a code 1 or 2 like a player’s and on the Unit+0x4E = 4 case. |
[C] | MonSeqFrame |
skills/dispatch n6 |
| Q361 | A missed piercing missile has spent a pierce. | [C] | — | skills/missiles n6 |
| Q362 | A used pierce keeps the missile: stat 328 falls by 1 and it flies on. | [C] | MissilePierceUse |
skills/missiles n7 |
| Q363 | A freed missile at a bit-0 or bit-2 own cell does not explode. | [I] | MissileMoveCollide |
skills/missiles n9 |
| Q364 | Do not sum stat lists at read time: model the cache and its propagation order, which is stale by design in places. | [C] | StatRecompute |
stats/aggregate n1 |
| Q365 | op 11 is a percentage of the flat sum, and op 8/9 count only the non-base part of energy and vitality. | [C] | StatEvaluate |
stats/aggregate n3 |
| Q366 | A target is written twice when its source recomputes it; the second write changes nothing and fires no callback unless the target is itself a source whose own target took (no stock case). | [C] | StatRecompute |
stats/aggregate n4 |
| Q367 | A state refresh does not rewrite the stats; only the end frame moves. | [C] | STATE_ApplyTimed |
stats/states n1 |
| Q368 | A lower level of a held state is refused, not queued. | [C] | STATE_ApplyTimed |
stats/states n3 |
| Q369 | The group test is not in the apply: only callers that run STATE_GroupClear exclude a group. |
[C] | STATE_GroupClear, STATE_ApplyTimed (its nine call sites and the closure by a second tool, S4d) |
stats/states n4 |
| Q370 | Shrines share the curse slot: a shrine removes the player’s curse, and the next curse removes the shrine’s state. | [I] | States.txt:curse, STATE_ApplyTimed |
stats/states n5 |
| Q371 | A player’s run speed is the walk base plus a +50 stat-67 list that lives while the run lasts; a monster runs at its walk path speed unless its AI command carries a velocity. | [I] | RunVelocityStat, MonModeVelocity |
anim/movement n1 |
| Q372 | Two bases: the path speed moves the unit, the animation base only paces the animation; both take the same factor X. |
[C] | UNIT_AnimSetRate |
anim/movement n2 |
| Q373 | A shapeshifted player takes the form’s record, start frame and rate, with the mode mapped through g_PlrToMonMode and the MonStats2 fallback. |
[C] | UNIT_AnimTransform |
anim/timing n4 |
| Q460 | Champions and uniques pick from umon in Normal only; in Nightmare and Hell they come from the region pool. |
[C] | MonRegionPickClass, Levels.txt:umon1 |
monsters/pool |
| Q461 | Prevent Monster Heal’s hook tests for a player attacker, so stat 117 on a mercenary’s items applies no state. | [I] | PreventHealHook |
combat/to-hit § A |
| Q488 | The drop’s base room moves between lookups: a fixed-room search agrees with all 118 live searches, on open ground, and still fails on declared rooms. | [C] | — | items/inventory n1 |
| Q489 | A player’s inventory search and any other owner’s differ, in score against first fit and in the one-cell-high order. | [C] | InvSpotFindBySize |
items/inventory n4 |
| Q490 | DropGoldAmount passes fallback 0; every other direct drop passes 1. |
[C] | the 20 search sites and the four pair-form drop bodies by a second tool (S4c) | items/inventory n6 |
| Q491 | The AI row kind follows the stored state, not the class: a unit in state 12 (kind 0) skips the search, when the gate allows it, even when its class’s row has kind 1. | [C] | MonAiTargetByKind |
monsters/ai/README n4 |
| Q492 | A planner’s grid is the live one after PathPlan’s unmarks: a unit does not block itself, nor a target under flag 0x800. An unmark there can take a neighbour’s 0x1000, and the tail’s re-mark gives back only the marked unit’s footprint. |
[I] | — | path/README n1 |
| Q493 | PathPlan’s refusals differ: step 5 clears nothing, the others clear +0x24, +0x28 and flag 0x20. |
[C] | — | path/README n3 |
| Q494 | The search refuses a free straight line and path type 1 accepts one; do not merge their reductions. | [C] | — | path/search n1 |
| Q495 | The line reads the path’s fields and the walk the context’s; knockback’s line starts at ctx.start, greedy’s at the position. |
[C] | — | path/search n2 |
| Q496 | The two copies of the grid mark a corpse differently: a server model takes the 3×3 at the death and keeps the record’s pattern and mask; the plus at pattern 5 is the client’s. | [C] | — | drlg/collision n9 |
| Q497 | The skill-tab bonus (stat 188) reaches a skill through its SkillDesc SkillPage, not through any Skills column. |
[I] | SkillDesc.txt:SkillPage |
skills/dispatch n10 |
| Q528 | An empty link slot is not a seam: LevelBorderAdj makes an adjacency node only for Vis ≠ 0 and Warp −1, and an empty slot also has Warp −1. |
[C] | LevelBorderAdj |
drlg/outdoor n13 |
7. Timing and frame edges
Section titled “7. Timing and frame edges”| Id | Quirk | Tag | Anchors | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q374 | A scheduled mode’s end is n frames after its start; the community breakpoint tables count N = n − 1. With the stock client a held normal action restarts at T + N, held Lightning at T + n; the server starts the next action in the frame its request arrives. |
[C] | SUNIT_ScheduleModeEvents |
anim/timing n1; anim/README n2 |
| Q375 | A scheduled mode does not follow a rate change: its events stay where its start put them; an every-frame monster takes the new rate at its next advance. | [C] | UNIT_AnimSetRate |
anim/README n1 |
| Q376 | Two rate calls per server start: the first, before +0x48 is written, sees the previous mode’s length; the schedule uses the second. |
[C] | UNIT_AnimInit, SUNIT_AnimInit |
anim/timing n2 |
| Q377 | A monster’s frame-function result is ignored: an every-frame attack or skill mode with no end call of its own lasts until another command. | [I] | MonModeFrameEvent |
anim/timing n5 |
| Q378 | A frozen monster loses its scheduled events (dropped and freed), its mode end among them. | [I] | MonEventDispatch |
anim/timing n7 |
| Q379 | A monster attack and its MonAttackStats are two moments: the El draws at the attack mode start, to-hit and build at the hit frame, with the monster’s AI drawing in between. |
[C] | MonAttackStats |
combat/README n6 |
| Q380 | A start-built hit (Bash and the other start-32 rows) rolls to-hit, defence and damage when the mode starts and delivers on the action frame; Jab (do 7) does everything at the action frame. | [I] | SkillSt32Hit, SKILL_MeleeDeliverDo |
skills/dispatch n3 |
| Q381 | A missile steps first on the frame after its creation. | [C] | — | skills/missiles n5 |
| Q382 | The frame pass runs missiles, players, monsters, objects, then the fifth list, so a missile steps before any unit acts in its frame. | [I] | GameRunUnitEvents |
skills/README n1; skills/missiles n5 |
| Q383 | A missile’s weapon terms are frozen at creation: its damage does not follow a weapon swap. | [I] | MissileDamageBlock |
skills/missiles n2 |
| Q384 | Rooms are released one by one as their own idle counts run out, per room, not per level. | [C] | RoomReleaseAllowed |
drlg/lifecycle § E; drlg/lifecycle n1 |
| Q385 | Count release passes, not frames: a visit between two passes leaves the idle count running. | [C] | — | drlg/lifecycle § E; drlg/lifecycle n2 |
| Q386 | The first kill always gets the quest TC: the drop runs inside the death mode change, before the quest scripts receive the death. | [C] | UnitKilled |
items/quest-drops n1 |
| Q387 | An act change by waypoint does not reset the old act’s stores in single player; it marks stale those built more than 240 000 ms before, a GetTickCount test (wall-clock: the act branch is the trap, the clock is kept as the spec gives it). A waypoint within the act resets them at once. |
[C] | NPCSTORE_ActStale |
items/vendors n10 |
| Q388 | A trap fires later: OBJ_TrapFire only queues event 4, and the effect comes 35 frames later among the timer events. |
[C] | OBJ_TrapFire, OBJ_TrapEvent |
objects n14 |
| Q389 | An NPC act change moves the player before it writes the travel word. | [C] | NPC_MenuAction, NpcActTravel |
quests/travel § E; quests/travel n4 |
| Q390 | While +0x4C = 1 the player can operate nothing and open no waypoint menu until packet 0x48. |
[I] | OBJ_OperateDispatch, PlayerIsBusy |
quests/travel § E; quests/travel n5 |
| Q391 | Equipment requirements are checked once per refresh, and the refresh also runs on its own from the act clock pass (idle gap 136 frames in 22 of 28 kept logs). | [C] | EquipReqRefresh, ActsClockPass (S4e part 5f) |
stats/aggregate n6 |
| Q392 | Queue one end event per state apply and per refresh, and let a stale one fire: it frees only lists whose end frame has passed. | [C] | EVENT_TimedListExpire |
stats/states n2 |
| Q498 | A monster’s drop has +0x24 0 and a player’s does not, so “items last 10 minutes” holds for one of them only, on the path run. |
[C] | — | items/inventory n2 |
| Q499 | The save recomputes a ground item’s expiry, so leaving a room can lengthen any item’s life, a player’s drop too. | [C] | — | items/inventory n3 |
| Q500 | The AI has two entries, the queue and a mode end; at a mode end it runs inside that mode-end event, so its draws come at that event’s place in the frame, not at the kind-2 record’s. | [C] | MonAiEvent |
sim/frame n8; monsters/ai/README n1 |
| Q501 | Idle queues; a think that queues nothing leaves no kind-2 record, so such a unit next thinks at a mode’s end. AI row 6 cancels its pending event on every decision. |
[I] | UNIT_CancelEvents, AiFallen |
monsters/ai/README n2 |
| Q502 | The frame stamp a packet reads is the frame before the one it acts in: handlers run with Game+0xA8 = N after tick N, and their effect is seen by tick N + 1’s passes. |
[C] | SrvDrainMessages |
sim/frame n1 |
| Q503 | EventQueueAt with frame −1 drops its callback, and a frame at or below the current one is raised rather than refused. |
[C] | — | sim/frame n2 |
| Q504 | An event slot holds records of later multiples of 64: a walk passes over a record whose frame is not the current one and keeps it. | [C] | MonEventsRun |
sim/frame n4 |
| Q505 | So a record due at F, queued in frame q, is passed over (F − q − 1) ÷ 64 times in the frames after q, and once more in frame q itself when F ≡ q (mod 64) and that frame’s walk reaches it. |
[I] | EventQueueAt |
sim/frame n5 |
| Q506 | The new-rooms flag is cleared after the walk, so a room created during its own act’s walk waits; do not re-walk. | [C] | — | sim/frame n6 |
8. Multiplayer edges
Section titled “8. Multiplayer edges”| Id | Quirk | Tag | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q393 | The player count raises the crushing-blow divisor through the monster’s stat 100 (its creation count). | [C] | combat/delivery n2; combat/README n7 |
| Q394 | The player count is frozen at a monster’s creation: /players changes nothing on live monsters, and stat 100 keeps the creation count. |
[C] | monsters/stats n3 |
| Q395 | Single player reads the L- MonLvl columns (3 954 creations). |
[C] | monsters/stats n2 |
| Q396 | The TC party rule is “same level”, not “two screens”. | [C] | items/tc n5 |
| Q397 | /players is a floor on the player count, not an addition, in single player (type 3) and on a TCP/IP host (type 2), where only the server’s setting counts. |
[C] | items/tc n6 |
| Q398 | Game type 1 also takes /players; other types do not. |
[I] | items/tc n6 |
| Q399 | Ladder uniques drop in single player and TCP/IP: the one ladder bit is ignored whenever Game+0x6A ≠ 0. |
[C] | items/uniques-sets n5 |
| Q400 | The forge makes n gems per wave, per credited player. |
[I] | items/quest-drops n9 |
| Q401 | Server units do not use the room seed: the room-seed rule is the client’s, and a server-side reimplementation seeds monsters, objects, NPCs and items from the game seed. | [C] | rng/seeds n7 |
| Q402 | The client copy of a preset room has more units: the river objects are added only with the client flag (flags bit 0). |
[C] | drlg/preset n8 |
| Q403 | The saved map seed survives only in single player, without -seed, and only for the difficulty saved in. |
[C] | save/d2s n4 |
| Q450 | The party distance is measured from the killed monster, not from the killer or the credited player, and the credited player is tested like every member (the code’s map; no logged kill separates it). | [C] | player/party n1; player/creation § J |
| Q451 | With one member collected, the award goes to the credited player at its own level, whoever that member was; with none, nobody gets anything (the code’s map; no logged kill separates it). | [C] | player/party n2; player/creation § J |
| Q452 | What Q450 and Q451 lead to in play: a far hireling’s or summon’s kill can pay its far owner alone or nobody, and a dead killer can be paid while the living member is not. | [I] | player/party n3; player/creation § J |
| Q453 | A credited player in no party has no alive or distance test; only the party branch has them. | [C] | player/party n4; player/creation § G |
| Q507 | ActsClockPass refreshes every client’s player on any act’s clock change, not only that act’s clients; only the packet goes to the act’s. |
[I] | sim/frame n10 |
| Q532 | Any inventory move request of a trading player un-accepts both players (state 7), even one the server then refuses: a cube with contents, a belt with potions, a quest code the partner holds. | [C] | items/trade n3 |
| Q533 | A trade’s cancel, close or abort rebuilds the whole inventory from the snapshot taken at opening, not only the offered items: items moved on page 0 go back to their opening cells and every item comes back as a new unit with a new id. | [C] | items/trade n4 |
| Q534 | A refusal at the trade’s commit does not close the trade: TradeCancel keeps the records and interactions, empties both offers and the gold, and the window is open again at state 3. |
[C] | items/trade n5 |
| Q535 | A trade’s gold offer is clipped when it is made, to the receiver’s room under its cap, and the stored amount is what the commit moves. | [C] | items/trade n6 |
| Q536 | The trade’s gold button (8) writes no state: a gold offer alone leaves a partner’s accept standing; the stock client’s button 7 before each entry is what un-accepts. | [I] | items/trade n7 |
| Q537 | A player saved mid-trade is saved with the opening snapshot of its item list, not the live list. | [C] | items/trade n8 |
| Q538 | Waypoint travel ends no trade: the traveller’s interaction is cleared and both trade states and records stay. | [I] | items/trade n10 |
9. Deliberate oddities that look like bugs
Section titled “9. Deliberate oddities that look like bugs”These are faithful 1.14d behaviour that reads as a mistake, or that contradicts a community description. Keep them.
| Id | Quirk | Tag | Anchors | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q404 | No bias correction: the RNG takes low mod n directly, with no rejection of the top partial range. |
[C] | — | rng/README n5 |
| Q405 | ToHitFactor is a class constant added to the base attack rating before the percent; the chance to hit’s level term 2·alvl/(alvl + dlvl) has no class term (contradicts the community description). BlockFactor is added to stat 20 in the block chance. |
[C] | PlayerBaseToHit, CharStatsRec+0x3C, UnitBlockChance |
combat/to-hit n1; player/creation n8; combat/README n7 |
| Q406 | Crushing blow is a share of the defender’s current life before this hit’s damage, 1/4 on uniques and champions, not the community’s 1/8 (52 crushing blows on champions took 1/4). | [C] | STATEVENT_CrushingBlow |
combat/delivery n1; combat/README n7 |
| Q407 | Burning never applies from a plain attack: the builder leaves burn = 2 with burnLen = 0. |
[C] | — | combat/delivery n15 |
| Q408 | The fire length is overwritten by the burn length in stat 315. | [C] | — | skills/missiles n4 |
| Q409 | dm78 lacks the lvl < 1 guard of the other dm codes: at level 0 it gives min(Par7, Par8) rather than 0. |
[C] | — | data/calc n8 |
| Q410 | The outdoor road search’s step cost is always 2; the 3 for a diagonal step is never taken by its 4-neighbour moves. | [C] | A1PathSearchStep |
drlg/outdoor n11 |
| Q411 | place_group25 keeps 3/4 and place_group75 keeps 1/4; do not swap them to match the names. |
[C] | — | drlg/preset n2 |
| Q412 | The hireling experience curve is cubic, (L + 1)·L²·Exp/Lvl, not quadratic. |
[C] | HIRELING_ExpForLevel |
hirelings n7 |
| Q413 | Affixes use alvl, not ilvl, for the level window and weights; the community “qlvl ≤ ilvl + 2, uniform” rule describes only the version-0 body. | [C] | — | items/affixes n3 |
| Q414 | Rares have 3 to 6 affixes, not 2 to 6, and both names are drawn first, independent of the affixes. | [C] | g_RareAffixCountTable |
items/affixes n5 |
| Q415 | Ladder cube rows work offline; op 28 is ≥ the difficulty; the rune socket rows roll 1..6 for every class; the Pandemonium portals do nothing. Each contradicts a community description. | [C] | CUBE_PandemoniumPortalStub |
items/cube n4 |
| Q416 | NPC sell mult scales P, what the player pays (the buy price); buy mult scales S, what the NPC pays. |
[C] | — | items/economy n2 |
| Q417 | Superior is not “max”: funcs 1, 2 and 13 roll in mode 1 (a D2R-era description does not describe 1.14d). | [C] | PROP_Func01_Roll |
items/properties n6 |
| Q418 | Magic find is linear up to 10 (F = mf + 100 for mf ≤ 10) in all four tests, mf·k/(mf + k) only above; the 1.10/1.11 formula has no linear branch. |
[C] | — | items/quality n3 |
| Q419 | Classic drops use the Version 1 ItemRatio rows, not the two Version 0 rows of the 1.10 description. |
[C] | — | items/quality n4 |
| Q420 | gemoffset is the child’s in 1.14d, not the later “starting index into gems” reading of the parent’s column. |
[C] | ITEMS_AttachToOwner, Weapons.txt:gemoffset |
items/sockets-runewords n6 |
| Q421 | Unique rarity weights in classic games too; no version test touches the weight. |
[C] | — | items/uniques-sets n6 |
| Q422 | A TC-named unique still needs enabled and lvl ≤ ilvl; a disabled row falls to the ordinary weighted pick (D2R’s documentation says otherwise). |
[I] | — | items/uniques-sets n7 |
| Q423 | Monster level ignores Levels.MonLvl1..3: logged classic Nightmare and Hell take MonStats Level*, expansion and classic Normal MonStats Level. |
[C] | MonStatsInit |
monsters/pool n10 |
| Q424 | MonUMax is per attempt and 6/100: the roll is made for each attempt that passed density, succeeds for r ≤ 5, and compares the cap with the live special count. |
[C] | — | monsters/spawn n3 |
| Q425 | MonWndr gates only the wanderer roll, not a roam/stand behaviour. |
[C] | MonRegionsBuild |
monsters/spawn n4 |
| Q426 | Dead code: the type-1 champion group (branch, FormationGroup) is never dispatched; do not implement it. |
[C] | FormationGroup |
monsters/spawn n1 |
| Q427 | Spectral Hit is + 20, and a unique’s strong uses ChampionDamageBonus; 1.14d differs from the community pages. |
[C] | — | monsters/stats n9 |
| Q428 | UniqueDamageBonus is not read. |
[I] | DifficultyRec |
monsters/stats n9 |
| Q429 | MonPlayerBonus writes the game’s difficulty byte to 2 when it is ≥ 3. |
[I] | MonPlayerBonus |
monsters/stats n10 |
| Q430 | The forced-slot bug: the rule reads Objects[groupIndex].SubClass, not a member’s; testing the member or the group’s SHRINES flag changes which slots are suppressed. |
[C] | — | objects n3 |
| Q431 | Objects use MonLvl1 in every difficulty, and shrines test LevelMin against the level Id; neither is the difficulty’s monster level. |
[C] | Levels.txt:MonLvl1, Shrines.txt:LevelMin |
objects n8 |
| Q432 | The guide’s numbers 1.14d does not follow: urns drop at 21 %, not 20 %; gold piles are 1–9, not 1–10; a sparkle chest uses the act chest TC. | [C] | — | objects n16 |
| Q433 | Quest bit 15 survives: only word 9’s first-join check clears it, so a character that saved with a reward pending carries it on. | [I] | — | quests/progression § A |
| Q434 | The ally test of StartUsedSkill is dead: do not add a refusal there. |
[C] | — | skills/dispatch n8 |
| Q435 | The stat take test for ops 2–5 reads the source row’s +0x0DE + 6k word, strength (0) on every stock source; do not “fix” it to op base. |
[C] | — | stats/aggregate n2 |
| Q441 | Words read before anything writes them: do 57’s block word +0x24 is the frame slot ebp−0x10, do 140’s class out word is EBP − 0x1C, and mhit 52’s class word +0x10 is never written; keep the stale values, which only a logged case gives. |
[C] | — | skills/catalogue n3 |
| Q442 | What follows from mhit 52’s unwritten class word: its missiles are row 0 by the callee’s reading. | [I] | — | skills/catalogue n3 |
| Q443 | Return values that look wrong: mdo 14 with a skill or level ≤ 0 returns 2 without running mdo 1, and do 63 returns 1 for a bad missile class. | [C] | — | skills/catalogue n6 |
| Q444 | do 13 returns 0 on every path. | [C] | SkillDo13Fend |
skills/catalogue n6 |
| Q445 | No Uber event was found in this image to port: classes 704, 705 and 709 have no creator and no Uber-specific driver found, within the limits the source states; keep their class-gated code. | [I] | AiUberDiablo, AiUberBaal, AiUberMephisto |
monsters/special n12 |
| Q462 | Dragon Talon’s knockback chance reads the target’s level twice, level(target) + slvl − level(target), so the level difference is slvl. |
[C] | SkillDo42DragonTalon |
skills/catalogue § M |
| Q463 | Psychic Hammer’s knockback chance has the same form: both level reads are the target’s. | [C] | SkillDo33PsychicHammer |
skills/catalogue § M |
| Q464 | Stat 137 counts twice with boots worn, on the kicks SkillKickPhysDamage builds: once alone, once with the boots’ values. |
[I] | KickItemDamage |
skills/dispatch § I |
| Q465 | The ToHit columns of Power Strike, MonPowerStrike and MonIceSpear do not reach st 6’s hit test, which passes an attack-rating percent of 0. |
[I] | SKILLS_GetToHit, SkillSt06Hit |
skills/catalogue § H |
| Q466 | Do 150 (Smite) has no access to Unit+0xC4, so it does not set the flag 0x40 do 2 sets there; the callees past COMBAT_ResolveAndQueue and COMBAT_DeliverQueued are unfollowed. |
[I] | — | skills/catalogue § J |
| Q467 | A monster’s Smite passes mode 5 to MonAttackStats whatever mode it used, so it takes its A2 stats. |
[C] | MonAttackStats |
skills/catalogue § J; monsters/stats § H |
| Q468 | El2 and El3 take El1’s minimum, maximum and length, through MonLvlStats’ mask 0x40 + e. |
[I] | MonLvlStats |
monsters/stats § H |
| Q469 | A manahit boss takes 256·v mana where the same value through an El column takes v, capped by the mana held; v << 22 wraps i32 at 512. |
[I] | UModManaHit, COMBAT_RollElemStat |
combat/delivery § B; monsters/stats § G |
| Q470 | A summon gets its MonLvl defence and to-hit added whole, with no noRatio test. |
[C] | SummonSetLevel |
skills/dispatch § L |
| Q471 | A monster’s line missile counts stat 19 twice, as the missile’s arPct from the creation and as the stat at the hit, when the record byte +0x18B is set; the dexterity term is not doubled, and the lob form sets no flag. |
[I] | SkillMissileCreate, MISSILE_HitUnit, COMBAT_ToHitRoll |
combat/to-hit § A; skills/missiles § E |
| Q472 | Neither skill creator adds a skill’s to-hit bonus to a player’s missile; do 74 (Double Throw) is the one exception read, and other creators are unfollowed. | [I] | SkillMissileCreate, SkillMissileCreateLob, SKILLS_GetToHit |
skills/missiles § B; skills/catalogue § K |
| Q473 | Blessed Aim and Penetrate both name penetrate in passivestate, so a running Blessed Aim removes Penetrate’s list from its caster. |
[I] | AURA_ApplyToTarget, Skills.txt:passivestate |
skills/catalogue § J |
| Q474 | A monster’s drain roll takes the packet’s field as its base, and the result is added to that field: field + max(field + roll, 0) × srcdam ÷ 128, so a drain already in the packet counts again. |
[I] | COMBAT_RollElemStat |
combat/damage § A |
| Q508 | MonItemPercent loads but no code reads it: a monster’s death drop chooses no row, makes no draw and steps no seed for it. Do not gate a drop on TreasureClassPercent. |
[I] | MonItemPctLoad, MonItemPctGetRecord, TC_ResolveDrops |
items/tc n1 |
| Q509 | The inventory packet 0x18 sets the page before the placement, so a refused item carries the new page byte. |
[I] | — | items/inventory n5 |
| Q510 | elx does not read its row’s stat1 and calc1. |
[C] | ItemUseElixir |
items/use n3 |
| Q511 | A first identify request consumes nothing; the second, on an unidentified item in the user’s inventory, does. 0x27 does not clear the marks first. |
[I] | ItemUseIdentifyTest |
items/use n4 |
| Q512 | A belt scroll used on an item does not shift its column, every other belt use does, and a used belt scroll on a target not in a grid is removed unused. | [I] | — | items/use n5 |
| Q513 | Packet 0x61 consumes the cursor item whatever ItemUse returned. |
[I] | — | items/use n6 |
| Q514 | Do not refuse on a use handler’s “3” at the drain: the return is discarded. | [C] | the return read by neither frame (S4b) | items/use n7 |
| Q515 | One life reader: AiLifePct is push ecx; call UnitLifePct; ret, one map with two calling conventions; AI rows 4, 8, 15 and 122 call it as AiLifePct, row 11 as UnitLifePct. |
[C] | UnitLifePct, AiLifePct |
monsters/ai/catalogue n3 |
| Q516 | AI row 21’s Idle does not return: the walk runs in the same event. |
[I] | — | monsters/ai/machinery n2 |
| Q517 | A leader’s stack block carries four words the code does not write, and row 30 reads +0x0C/+0x10 of a kind-1 head record for its GameFindUnit. |
[I] | — | monsters/ai/machinery n5 |
| Q518 | AI row 34’s override type 1 plans type 7, so Ovr(1, …) is no type-1 request. |
[C] | MonAiPathOverride |
monsters/ai/machinery n6 |
| Q519 | PathPlan’s tail re-marks the unit even when the free step returned 0; a plan’s tail is one of the two things that end the unmarked state. |
[I] | — | path/README n2 |
| Q520 | PathReplan changes the path type without the flags. |
[I] | — | path/README n4 |
| Q521 | Knockback clears the path’s target unit whether or not it finds a point. | [C] | — | path/README n5 |
| Q522 | 0x8000 is written but in no immediate move mask scanned: on what the path spec states, a corpse mark is not a blocker. |
[I] | PATH_MonTestMask |
path/README n6 |
| Q523 | unflatDead changes no grid mark and no move mask: its one direct reader is a client draw-list test. |
[C] | — | path/README n7 |
| Q524 | The plan of path type 14 reads no grid; the hammer’s end at a wall is the missile’s own step. | [I] | MissileMoveCollide |
path/README n8 |
| Q525 | A greedy walk’s oddities are behaviour to keep: the doubled first point, the point short at a turned last step, the reversal’s end. | [C] | — | path/search n5 |
| Q526 | Do not reset g_HitClassCounter per game. |
[C] | — | sim/frame n9 |
| Q527 | Events 4 and 8 never fire: keep stat 195’s domissileattack registration inert; dispatching it on a missile attack adds casts the game does not make. |
[I] | UNIT_DispatchEvent |
skills/dispatch n9 |
| Q530 | The trade’s room test fills scratch grids in the non-player FIRST order, the moves place in the player’s BEST order: a test that passes can be followed by a move that fails, and the snapshots then undo the side that already moved. | [C] | TradeRoomTest, TradeMoveItems |
items/trade n1 |
| Q531 | The trade’s FIRST room test can refuse an offer the BEST moves would place; keep the test, do not replace it with a trial of the real placement. | [I] | TradeRoomTest |
items/trade n2 |
Crash and hang paths
Section titled “Crash and hang paths”Six from the specs’ code readings and three reached in kept runs: Q89, a fault logged on row 83, Q437, the fatal path reached under emulation on three paths of the catalogue, and Q448, the same call reached under emulation by a party’s ninth member (Q449: past that call is unread, and a list holds at most 8 players, so no stock game reaches it). The entries are in their classes above: Q44, Q45, Q50, Q65, Q74, Q89, Q93, Q437, Q448; Q50’s hang is also the catalogue’s endless-loop note.
Community claims
Section titled “Community claims”Agreement with a page raises no tag: each entry states what the code does, in the owning spec’s words. Every verdict lands here once, and a check holds this table to the compared verdicts.
Community claims that do not hold
Section titled “Community claims that do not hold”A reimplementer must not “restore” these. No reviewed statement changes because of them.
| Row | The claim | What the code does | Tag | Statement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 | Melee monsters with life, mana or stamina steal do twice the damage | No field counts twice on the El path. A non-hireling monster’s life drain is one term of total, added to the physical damage, which it does not repeat. |
[C] | combat/reductions § A |
| 12 | (the same) | El type life writes only stats 60 and 61; mana and stamina leave stats 8 and 10 and are not in total. What can double is a drain already in the packet (Q474). |
[I] | combat/delivery B4, combat/damage step 5 |
| 20 | Curse resistance cuts every timed list, Fade’s among them | The cut on a player target is as stated. | [C] | stats/states B1 |
| 20 | (the same) | The cut runs only if curse, the state’s curse flag, and fade has that cell blank. |
[I] | stats/states B1 |
| 26 | Hratli’s magic level is 1, by a misspelled header | The header is right about the cause, and the value is 0, the absent-column default. | [C] | items/vendors D3 |
| 28 | Eth’s target defence reduction goes negative, so it works as “ignores target defence”, on bosses too | The percent is clamped to 0..100 and halved on a boss, player, superunique or hireling. | [I] | combat/to-hit A7 |
| 3 | Kick skills receive elemental damage from weapons | Not in 1.14d on the four Kick rows: Kick’s start 2 skips the build, and SkillKickPhysDamage unlinks the damage stats of a weap item in either hand before it builds. Elemental stats from other items still reach that build. |
[I] | skills/dispatch I4 |
| 25 | Some runeword property codes are misspelled | Not in 1.14d: 0 unknown codes in 508 T1Code cells of 169 rows. |
[C] | items/sockets-runewords E2 |
| 29 | The “n−1” bug: a ranged modifier never reaches its maximum | Not in 1.14d: lo + Range(hi − lo + 1). |
[C] | items/properties D1 |
Coverage
Section titled “Coverage”One row per spec with a Reimplementation notes section: its note count, the notes taken (cited by at least one entry), and the skipped ones by reason. “Weaker duplicate” is a note that restates, at a weaker tag, a statement another spec holds raised; the entry takes the raised statement, and the disagreement goes to the spec with the weaker tag (the three overviews named in the backlog entry now state the raised clause). Skipped: 32 notes, presentation 5, table rule 12, not a trap 12, wall-clock 3.
Q454–Q473 take the step notes the community verdicts name, and Q474 combat/damage § A’s step 5 note: it answers no verdict of its own, and row 12’s “does not hold” text points at it.
Evidence
Section titled “Evidence”Every entry links its owning spec section; the specs carry the findings, runs and table docs.